Creative uses of constitutional court authority to advance substantive justice eric c. Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism karl e klare our function is to interpret the text of the constitution as it stands. Klare legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 14 sajhr 146188 at 150. K klare legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 14 sajhr 146, 153.
I use critical thinking as referring to both thinking about and judging law and society in order to. According to karl klare, transformative constitutionalism connotes an enterprise of inducing largescale social change through nonviolent political processes grounded in law. Jun 29, 2019 transformative constitutionalism in south africa. Transformative constitutionalism and customary law saflii. It has been more than a decade since karl klare introduced the term transformative constitutionalism in his seminal article legal culture and transformative constitutionalism into the legal landscape of south africa. Aug, 2012 karl klare legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 14 sajhr 146. This chapter considers constitutionalism and rights discourse as emancipatory and egalitarian political strategies. See k klare legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 14 sajhr 146, 150. Langa p transformative constitutionalism 200617 stellenbosch law. Some questions from the past and from afar, 18 industrial law journal 588 1997. Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 14 south. Harvard law school institute for global law and policy uncategorized karl e.
In the legal field, transformation also refers to a radical overhaul of the formalistic legal culture, away from in the words of etienne mureinik a culture of authority to. The controversy sparked by attorney richard spoors recent remarks which boils down to i basically only brief white counsel because only white counsel is prepared to work for a reduced rate and only white counsel is exceptional and therefore, acceptable, again raised the spectre of what unites. Us scholar professor karl klares work titled the legal culture and transformative constitutionalism, published in 1998 in the south african journal of human rights, paved to way for much subsequent. Transformative constitutionalism connotes an enterprise of inducing largescale social change through nonviolent political processes grounded in law. Karl klare legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 14 sajhr 146.
Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism. Klare, legal culture and transformative constitutionalism, 14 south african j. A desire to structure a system of government and draft rights protections that. Thus, professor karl klare formulated the notion of tc. Klare legal culture transformative constitutionalism. Nov 26, 2019 us scholar professor karl klares work titled the legal culture and transformative constitutionalism, published in 1998 in the south african journal of human rights, paved to way for much subsequent debate and discussion. This dissertation module should demand that students engage critically with the principles of transformative constitutionalism in order to facilitate thinking that goes beyond traditional and conservative constructions of the. Written for a conference in celebration of the tenth anniversary of the publication of karl klares article on legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 sajhr 146, this paper argues that klares article, while justly celebrated, defines the project of transformative constitutionalism in too exclusive a fashion.
Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism karl e klare george j. Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism united. See, further, the discussion by m pieterse coming to terms with judicial enforcement of socioeconomic rights 2004 20 sajhr 383 417 at 389 of traditional characterisations of the different nature of civil and political rights on. In particular, he notes that despite the substantively postliberal and transformative aspirations12 of. Apartheid mentalities and the transformation of legal culture. Accordingly, whatever our personal views on this fraught subject capital punishment might be, our response must be a purely legal one.
Such transformative constitutions as the ones of india, south. What do we talk about when we talk about transformation. In particular, he notes that despite the substantively postliberal and transformative aspirations12 of our constitution, our. Transformative constitutionalism and the common and customary law. Transformative constitutionalism stellenbosch university. Drawing from the diverse experiences of south africa, israel, and canada, this chapter examines the arguments for and against social rights, testing them concretely by tracking the development of a right to healthcare in the three legal regimes. Part iii takes up the question of the autonomous role of legal culture in shaping and steering adjudication. Judges make law despite the fairy tales of legislation discovery that the public are told.
Pdf transformative constitutionalism in postcolonial. He is considered a leading voice in the field of critical legal studies. Justice mahomed once wrote, the south african constitution is different. Klare argued that as a progressive supporter of the democratic project, one not only could but should interrepret our constitution as a. These fairy tales have been more tenuous since the constitution conferred significant power on the judiciary to interrogate and renovate the common law our constitution did not come up. Transformative constitutionalism as semantic scholar. Study of legal reasoning, legal theory, and legal institutions 1987. It was mureinik 1 who pointed out that the true shift from apartheid to postapartheid south africa is a move from a culture of authority to a culture of justification a culture in which every exercise of power is expected to be. According to klare there are at least three discursive practices that lend themselves to the denial of judicial choice and responsibility. Harvard law school institute for global law and policy. This article reflects on the possibility of conceiving of the notion of transformative constitutionalism as a critical project. Our function is to interpret the text of the constitution as it stands.
Sabinet transformative constitutionalism and the best. This essay examines the question of whether transformative constitutionalism is a. Karl e klare 1998 legal culture and transformative. It argues that if a constitution aims to transform society, it cannot do it just by means of legal discourse.
Klare legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 sajhr 146 157. As a result, transformative constitutionalism as a legal concept is not a. In recent years, he has worked on numerous projects with lawyers in south africa. I and all of the graduates here assembled follow in their footsteps. In this poignant article klare explains that transformative constitutionalism connotes a. Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism free download as pdf file. Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism scinapse. M ist 4 karl klare, legal culture and transformative constitutionalism, 14 s.
By criticizing the liberal scope of the constitution, this work also emphasizes the need to advance a critical and transformative model of constitutionalism in order to promote a social construction and a major impact of human rights. In a seminal article published in 1998, american academic, karl klare coined the term transformative constitutionalism, which he went on to describe as a long term project of constitutional enactment, interpretation and enforcement committed to transforming a countrys political and social institutions and power relationships in a democratic participatory and egalitarian. Transformative constitutionalism of south africa has the purpose of transforming. Essay about transformative constitutionalism 1859 words. Conservative legal culture may induce an overly cautious approach constitutional interpretation.
Transformative constitutionalism by jaryd davidson on prezi. Back in 1998, a progressive american academic called karl klare wrote an extremely influential and since then much quoted article in which he argued that ours could be seen as a transformative constitution. Your use of this heinonline pdf indicates your acceptance of heinonlines. However, for those criticsand i include myself among them particularly interested in the. Three arguments raised in karl klares 1998 article, legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 sajhr 146 are highlighted. It is the south african experience that had initially prompted legal scholars to take note of the concept of transformative constitutionalism. Sabinet transformative constitutionalism as and critique. Thus, professor karl klare formulated the notion of tc, given the countrys system of constitutional supremacy and the constitutions values.
In particular, it unnecessarily requires, as a condition. Social rights, social citizenship, and transformative. Karl e klare, legal culture and transformative constitutionalism1998 1 4 south african journal of human r ights 150. Substantive justice is an everelusive goal for constitutionmakers. Karl e klare, legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 1 4 south african journal of human r ights 150.
According to karl klare, tc is the perfect architect for entrenching a legal. Transformative constitutionalism and the common and customary. Van marle 2009 stell lr 286301 expounds transformative constitutionalism as an embodiment of legal critique. Karl e klare 1998 legal culture and transformative constitutionalism, south african journal on human rights, 14. Transformative constitutionalism, legal culture and the. Transformative constitutionalism, 5 klare highlights what he terms the inherent. Transformative constitutionalism and the common and. Ups vibrant centre for human rights, founded during bleaker days in 1986, is. K klare legal culture and transformative constitutionalism 1998 14 south african journal on human rights 146 at 150. University of pretoria conferral of honorary degree ll.
See also recently transformative constitutionalism in latin america. Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism united states. Early in the constitutional era, karl klare wrote penetratingly about the legal. The late chief justice, addressing himself to what change is about, mentioned that it would be the frontrunner in constructing a new legal order, creating equal opportunities for. However, klare notes a disconnect between the prevailing legal culture in south africa and the commitment of the constitution11 to social change. The author identifies a disconnect between the 1996 constitutions transformative aspirations and the conservative character of south african legal culture. Pdf transformative constitutionalism in south africa. As i explain below, the concept was first used in relation to south african constitutionalism in karl e. Geoff budlender law and lawfulness in south africa. Transformative constitutionalism in postcolonial africa. Professor klare focuses on labor and employment law, human rights and legal theory, fields in which he has written and lectured extensively. Pdf transformative constitutionalism in postcolonial africa. S ee a lso stephen ross et a l, comparative constitutional law.
80 403 1001 224 1259 915 667 1321 392 1125 853 1317 76 165 36 162 1314 1367 362 233 1085 614 734 526 95 1355 242 1039 1134 1365 356 482 1022 994 1331 289 1229 1470 451 602 544 250 1331 598 1094 725